kamera.co.uk

film review   

   | FILM NEWS | FILM REVIEWS | BOOK REVIEWS | FEATURES | INTERVIEWS | FORUM | DIRECTORY | BOOKSHOP | BLOG | WHO WE ARE |

      home : reviews : film reviews : 8 Mile

8 Mile





Director: Curtis Hanson
Starring: Eminem, Kim Basinger, Mekhi Phifer, Brittany Murphy, Evan Jones



Related Links

8 Mile

Release Dates

Eminem official site


Merchandise Links

8 Mile (Region 2 DVD) - Amazon.co.uk





Eminem, aka Slim Shady, aka Marshall Mathers – a homophobic, misogynistic, gun-toting, mother-hating angry rapper, who is an expert at stirring up the middle-class hordes and providing a disruptive influence over today's youth. He's also a versatile linguist, an alliterator, enunciator, a master of rhyme and, well, not a bad actor, as it happens. That may be because in Curtis 'L.A Confidential' Hanson's 8 Mile he plays a genius rapper from the wrong side of the tracks, attempting to capitalise on his talents in the face of racial prejudice, abject poverty and family problems. Film debuts don't get much more autobiographical than this.

Rabbit (Eminem) is preparing himself for a rap 'battle' at The Shelter, a local Detroit nightclub, in which he and an adversary will attempt to diss one another and win over the crowd. He rehearses in the can, perfecting the all-important hand movements and brooding scowl needed for the performance – and promptly throws up. We soon learn that these lyrical sparring matches provide his only escape from an existence that otherwise consists of living with his trailer trash mom (Kim Basinger), working in a factory pressing car bumpers and avoiding his bunny-boiler girlfriend. Unfortunately, nerves get the better of him when it's his turn to counterattack, he freezes and flees the club humiliated. The remainder of the film sees him and his loyal homies dealing with inter-gang rivalry, living in a crumbling urban jungle and attempting to use music as a way of escaping poverty. And of course, there's the small matter of gaining revenge and making amends for Rabbit's balked performance at the Shelter – a sort of rapping Rocky.

8 Mile isn't a star vehicle designed to exploit a loyal fan-base, though – unlike Vanilla Ice in Cool as Ice (1991) or – ahem – the 'actors' known as the Spice Girls in Spice World (1997). Eminem, frankly, doesn't need the exposure. Still, Hanson seems to have based the film around Eminem's lyrical talents – the plot is merely a street-styled, hip-hop remix of an over-familiar format, and the movie's high points come during the rapper's amazingly witty and passionate verbal tirades. Also, Eminem's modus operandi is that he is a white rapper in a predominantly black musical genre, whose lyrics portray a depressed background. Audiences must have walked through the cinema doors expecting to see 'The Slim Shady Story', even if the film claims to be a work of fiction.

Musicians rarely make good actors. For every good performance, such as Meat Loaf in Fight Club (1999) or Björk in Dancer in the Dark (2000), there's a Damon Albarn in Face (1997) or Tina Turner in Mad Max: Beyond the Thunderdome (1985). Eminem falls somewhere in the middle; he excels in the musical scenes, but elsewhere in the film the icy stare he's clearly been encouraged to adopt occassionally crosses the fine line between attitude and inertia.

In the end, (cite)8 Mile(/cite} avoids the rags-to-riches clichés by leaving Rabbit teetering on the edge of success. It is an understated conclusion that avoids ending with a bang and instead simply allows the rapper to find his voice – the explosion coming from the expression of Rabbit's inner fury rather than some life-changing event. You've only got to hope that this isn't paving the way for a sequel (9 Mile?) where little Rabbit makes it big. Success might finally crack a smile on his stony face – but then again, that might prove a bit too testing for Eminem's acting skills.

Reviewed by Paul Clarke


Reader comments about 8 Mile

MELANIE ROSET (uk, reading) writes:

i thought ur film was brilliant. i was neva a big fan of eminem but since i've watched his film i relised that he is proper $exy (if u no wot i mean) i would love to meet him and dat girl dat he fucks she is one of da luckyist girls ever 2 have do that scene wiv him. Anywayz as soon as the dvd came out i bought it and watched it loads of times. we even done a big project in school about him and his film and his music. i have found out so much about him during the last couple of weeks its amazing but it seems he must of had a pretty hard life. Anywayzzzz gotta go and just want to say that EMINEM IS SO $EXY ITS UNBELIEVEABLE !?!


Daniela (skaby_1@hotmail.com) writes:

My comentary is that this movie is very agree and beautiful.

Eminem is a very actor and excelent singer but his life is very complete .

I'm the fanatic number one , he is my idol. Our think that the first movie was excelent he should do other.

Sincerely yours,

DANIELA SMITH


Jeancarlos Villegas Miranda (jeancarlos_777) writes:

que es una pelicula muy buena

Ya que quiero ser un RAPERO como el y lo quiero lograr y quero que el se comunique conmigo ya que hay le va mi correo jeancarlos_777 y quiero que me escriba.

y en cuanto el video esmuy bueno ya que narra como el se inicio de joven

yo soy peruano y quiero que me escriba

Iam peruviam


victoria walsh (walshie_1_vicky@hotmail.com) writes:

A famous rap artist, Eminem otherwise known as Slim Shady had decided to embark on the making of a film and came up with the idea of incorporating everyday life and his love of music into the production.

The media have created the image that this film has small resemblance with the rap-artist, and has nothing to do with Eminem’s life or childhood and is in fact a story pact with controversial ideas and a tale of determination and faith.

Eminem plays a character named Jimmy who is also known as Rabbit to his friends and Elvis to his enemies. Jimmy's story exists within a rough neighborhood district in Detroit where the drama takes place. Rap artistry takes place within ghetto, where social groups of multicultural backgrounds come together in a passionate battle against their opponent through lyrical expression.

Jimmy makes a living by working at a heavy machine company, making cars. Unfortunately, he realizes that he needs to earn more money and so decides to ask his Boss for more shifts. Upon hearing this requirement, his Supervisor looks at him with and expression of astonishment at the utter rudeness of his question. Our main character now realizes this is a ‘No Win’ situation and decides not to press this on any further.

The film commenced by informing us that Jimmy has split with his pregnant girlfriend. As an audience member, I feel the part of Jimmy’s girlfriend is underplayed and thus as a character, she is irresponsibly pushed to the side and neglected, whereas more emphasis could have been placed on her. The thing that I would change in the film would be concentrate more on the ex girl friend and see how the wellbeing of her unborn child is doing without the company of her boy friend (rabbit).

My favorite character was Jimmy as he had to cope with the difficult behavior of his Mother’s untrustworthy boyfriend. Jimmy is a strong character and Mathshall Mathers played the part accordingly to my expectations. This is as I think the character should be white (in order to emphasize the racial conflict) who has a strong mobility to use his strength to keep his anger to a low level throughout the scenes.

Mathshall Mathers took the role of the character immediately in to his own hands, as he was brave and trustworthy. Jimmy’s stance is slouched and week, emphasizing the fact that he is a gaunt boy in his late teens. The other opponents are black, stout and of large stance with lots of muscle tone. I am surprised Jimmy had the courage on his second attempt to dismiss him as he did so, because they were much bigger than him.

Jimmy leaves her his car to his ex because it is more important for her to have it, and that's all he has to offer. Jimmy is left with a problem of how to get to work on time,(his mum offers him a car) and he's already asking the his superviser for more hours. His mother (Kim Basinger) is beautiful women in her late 30’s, she is a poor, broken down mum who gets upset easily from her jobless sit-around boyfriend (Michael Shannon).

Jimmy, carrying his clothes around in a bin bag, decides to stay at his mum's home and has to cope with her lover (who is the same age as him). He constantly sulks and mopes around as a sign that he doesn't approve.

At a hip-hop club, Jimmy is set to perform, but then chokes before a black audience.

He's a white Elvis that doesn't belong making black music, at least that's how he feels. But towards the middle of the film Jimmy gets into conflict (not physically but verbally). He try’s again for a second time performing, this time he meets his requirements.

While most things are going well for Jimmy, his Mothers is being physically abused by her jobless boyfriend. Jimmy can’t take any more of it, so he shows him how he feels in front of his little sister Lilly and hits him across the face.

It takes half the movie before Jimmy has a crush on Alex (Brittany Murphy). But later on in the film he finds out Alex has been cheating on him. But, predictably so, everything ends up fine in the end and Jimmy follows on towards a successful career in rap artistry.

Finally Jimmy can go up on stage without choking and get on with verbal abuse to his opponent (at which point, I assumed this to be a strange ‘happy ending’).

In this film the love between Jimmy and his little sister Lillie is very strong. Like the way he sings the song to her and also comforts her when his mum is distraught.

The most important scenes in this movie is the hip hop club. The producer thought well to make this one of the most focussed part of the film.

As I had mentioned before, I find it crazy that Hanson could direct a film with a character who’s sole purpose is to get ‘good’ at having verbally abusive contests. Although the film was giving an age rating of fifteen, the producers must have known that by having such an influential rap star as their main character, they were obviously going to be making a film which will be watched by a lot of young children. If this is so then I think it is wrong to have such explicit feelings being encouraged to be expressed in the name of music.

In my opinion the film was just a way Eminem could show himself off to a wider audience, worldwide. The rating I wold give this film would be 4/10 as I didn’t really enjoy the film as much as I had expected. This is as, at first I believed critics words of it being a story which would give me a stronger view on rap and hip hop music and why it is so popular to people. Instead I got irritated with most of the characters’ ‘cheezyness’ and pathetic attitudes towards life.

After watching the film, I disagreed strongly with my first quote as I don’t think it is just a story of a poor little white boy wanting to become a rap star. In fact in Hanson's 8 Mile Mr. Mathers plays a genius rapper from the wrong side of town, attempting to reach his dream despite racial prejudice, poverty and family problems. Personally I think Mather’s first film doesn't get much more autobiographical than this.


Josh (JALH6789@yahoo.com) writes:

Eminem is my favorite rapper... and after this movie he became my favorite actor too, as much as Eminem tries to hid the fact that this is the story of his life, i can tell that Rabbits life is very similar to Marshall's the only thing different in the story that dosnt match the story heard in his lyrics is the fact that he has a good relationship with his mom, and that there never was a "better rapper" at the shelter like there was in Eminem AKA. i think this black and white shit needs to end for real though cause the more white people try to back away from racism against black people, the more black people push racism on white people, i noticed eminem has never said the "N word" in any of his lyrics but when he staarted people couldent stop being all shitty about a white rapper, its great though because he earned his respect because of his game. i think he should stay in the rap game though, and just do movies and music.


Bonnie (Email address withheld) writes:

i LOVE Eminem and 8 mile was tha greatest. i personally think i am eminem's biggest fan, and i even flew over from australia to america to see him. 8 mile was really kool n i think eminem did a fantastic job at playing jimmy. does any1 know where i can find the lyrics to that song jimmy sings to lily when he puts her to sleep? i would really appreciate it if someone told me. thank you.

-eminems biggest fan


Add your comments about 8 Mile [About]




UTILITIES


Search kamera.co.uk

Product finder



Browse our network:




| WHO WE ARE | BLOG | BOOKSHOP | DIRECTORY | FORUM | INTERVIEWS | FEATURES | BOOK REVIEWS | FILM REVIEWS | FILM NEWS |   


kamera.co.uk

Copyright © 1999/2004 kamera.co.uk