kamera.co.uk

film review   

   | FILM NEWS | FILM REVIEWS | BOOK REVIEWS | FEATURES | INTERVIEWS | FORUM | DIRECTORY | BOOKSHOP | BLOG | WHO WE ARE |

      home : reviews : film reviews : Stalker

Stalker





Director: Andrei Tarkovsky
Starring: Alexander Kaidanovsky, Anatoly Solonitsin, Nikolai Grinko, Alissa Freindlikh



Related Links

Stalker
IMDB

Release Dates
IMDB

Russian Cinema Council

Reviewer's web site





Merchandise Links

Buy the video (PAL format)



Related Books





For his innovative low-tech science fiction film Stalker (1979), Andrei Tarkovsky uses brilliant cinematic imagination to transform the ghostly-beautiful fields, streams and power plants of Tallinn, Estonia (in the then-Soviet Union) to the organic, industrial science fiction landscape of the Zone - a restricted, hazardous area rumored to contain paranormal power from the crash of a mysterious meteorite. The hard science fiction approach taken in Tarkovsky's epic Solaris (1972) is abandoned for a subtle, unaffected approach where fantastic elements are alluded to but rarely shown (much to the story's benefit) and fused to a narrative framework of "the journey," where protagonists travel to a predetermined destination in search of material or spiritual fulfillment (aka "the road trip"). Only in the hands of a genius like Tarkovsky can the simple narrative structure of three men on a journey be transformed to a complicated moral and spiritual examination of humanity, anchored to references of classical poetry, literature, music and art, filtered through the mesh of a personal life experience in a totalitarian society.

Alexander Kaidanovsky is Stalker, a man charged with guiding two men, Writer (Anatoly Solonitsin) and Professor (Nikolai Grinko), within the heavily-guarded Zone to a Room that holds the power to grant one wish (prayer?) to anyone who enters. Stalker lives in a sparse hovel with his wife (Alissa Freindlikh) and young daughter Monkey, who is unable to walk, perhaps due to a birth defect from her father's regular exposure to the Zone. Stalker's wife is painfully upset and confronts Stalker about his journey as he leaves the family bed to meet Writer and Professor. Unfazed, Stalker departs to rendezvous with the men at a bar. They board a jeep, and after carefully dodging law officers, enter the Zone by following a train through a barbed-wire passageway. Armed guards fire at them. The men escape the guards and locate a small motorized railroad trolley, which they use to travel deep into the Zone until Stalker stops them to continue on foot. The landscape of the Zone is beautiful, with lush, green fields and trees. Amongst the beauty, industrial utility lines and rusted military relics are scattered about. Stalker explains that the Zone is in constant flux and dangerous to navigate, and one can never travel the same path twice. Although the building housing the Room is visible a short distance away, Stalker will not take the direct route; rather, he travels via unexplained, mysterious, and often subterranean routes that he navigates by throwing ahead bolts tied to gauze bandages.

During the journey, Writer is talkative, often questioning society, his writing talent, and self-worth. Professor is more private, and when not arguing with Writer and Stalker, seems more concerned about the knapsack he's carrying. Neither man discloses their motive for visiting the Room. Stalker often communicates with Writer and Professor on a philosophical plane, and frequently refers to Porcupine, a stalker who hanged himself after an experience involving his brother in the Zone. After navigating through several surreal underground rooms, tunnels and caverns, Stalker delivers the men the Room's threshold, where he awaits their decisions about the Room.

Stalker is an accomplished, heady science fiction classic - one of the genre's best - but a very demanding, and sometimes inaccessible, viewing experience. On most days that's a compliment - cinema that continues to challenge the viewer and refuses to wholly disclose its mysteries is indeed a desirable but rare commodity. As populist science fiction veered towards pulp and tech in the late 1970s with films like the Star Wars trilogy (1977-1983) and Alien (1979), Stalker preserved science fiction as art, keeping alive the spirit of films like Chris Marker's La Jetée (1962), and influenced a new generation of filmmakers like Lars von Trier, who would begin his career soon thereafter with the Stalker-influenced The Element of Crime (1984).

On the surface, Stalker recalls W.W. Jacobs's familiar American short story "The Monkey's Paw," where earnest wishes have the potential of catastrophic consequence. But Tarkovsky's approach doesn't concern ironic twists of fate, but rather contemplates wishes as beacons of personal faith - not necessarily spiritual faith, although such an interpretation certainly has merit, but faith in whatever truth stirs within the individual soul. In many ways the Zone is a manifestation of Stalker's faith, a place where logic, science, and even Stalker's own rules - such as his edict that backtracking in the Zone is disastrous - have fleeting hold. The Zone's mysterious nature mirrors faith's elusiveness, and all three men undergo a crisis (test?) of faith in the Zone's landscape. Writer and Professor, figurative men of the arts and institutionalized knowledge, are asked to have dual faith in both Stalker's Zone and in the essence of their souls. Neither man is entirely successful - indeed, what man is when it comes to faith, even in faith in himself? - and ultimately it is Stalker's wife who poignantly shares the most convincing demonstration of faith in a heartfelt monologue at the end of the film.

The Russian Cinema Council (Ruscico) presents Stalker in a two-DVD set with a generous selection of interesting but sometimes brief extras. Disc 1, a single layer disc, presents Part One of the film; 10 behind-the-scenes production photographs, the best being a striking, overhead color photograph of the cast and crew at work when Stalker lays down before his dream; a brief Tarkovsky biography sans filmography, which is included on Disc 2; a 5m 43s short film Memory (although the DVD menu labels it "Tarkovsky's House"), a Stalker-inspired documentary film that combs through the weathered, junk-filled ruins of Tarkovsky's boyhood home, intercut with footage of Stalker's dream sequence, and brief audio samples and music themes from Stalker; and a 4m 53s excerpt of Tarkovsky's The Steamroller and the Violin aka Katok I Skyrpka, a 46-minute short film Tarkovsky filmed in 1960 for his diploma at VGIK, the All-Union State Institute of Cinematography. The Steamroller and the Violin segment is particularly exciting to sample, and we can only hope that the full short film eventually receives the full Ruscico treatment on DVD. Disc 2, a double layer disc, presents Part Two of the film; a 5m 44s interview with cameraman Alexander Knyazhinsky, poignantly titled "Alexander Knyzahinsky's last interview" as a weakened, terminally-ill Knyzahinksy is interviewed in his bathrobe at an assisted care facility; a 14m 21s interview with production designer Rashit Safiullan, who reminisces about Tarkovsky's precise attention to detail, and the devastating loss of the film's negative after it was halfway complete; and biographies/filmographies of 9 cast and crew members. Navigation menus on both discs may be accessed in Russian, English, or French text. Like Ruscico's Solaris DVD, Stalker contains a few substantial extras not advertised on the disc's packaging buried in the bios/filmographies section. In the bio for composer Eduard Artemyev, there is a fascinating 21m 7s interview that touches on a number of subjects, including Tarkovsky's use of composers to sculpt the sound design of films as opposed to strict score composition. Further in Artemyev's filmography, there is a brief teaser for the Solaris DVD, including a full 3m 20s English language trailer for the film. If you navigate to the same spot in the Russian or French menus, the trailer can be played in Russian or French, respectively.

Ruscico's visual presentation of Stalker is striking. Sepia sequences are a rich, deep brown, and quite distinctive from the film's color sequences, which are comprised of pleasant, subdued earth tones that emphasize the Zone's green vegetation. The source material is properly framed in a 1.37:1 aspect ratio and very clean, with no noticeable scratches, slugs, or other physical aberrations. The video compression is strong, with very light artifacting only briefly noted during scenes containing intense smoke or fog, such as the scene in the Zone where Stalker dispatches the trolley into thick fog. One audio choice is available for the film - a Russian language Dolby Digital 5.1 mix, which may be translated to 13 languages via subtitles (note that the subs can't be changed or turned off while on the fly). It's a solid, pleasing sound mix that features a very distinct separated right/left sound stage, but unfortunately it's been altered with additional (and sometimes removed) music and sound not present in Stalker's original mono mix. Most noticeable is the absence of the Beethoven's Ninth Symphony cue that ends the film (although the other classical music cue, Ravel's Bolero, is still present), and the addition of ambient music to supplement the previously solo rhythmic clanking of the railroad tracks during the trolley ride sequence into the Zone, but be aware that there are other instances of tinkering. After contacting Ruscico regarding the altered soundtrack, the company revealed that it "will produce the original version of Stalker in February/March" and that "it will be possible to change one version for another in a store where the first version were purchased."

Reviewed by Todd Harbour


Reader comments about Stalker

Tim Gray (timgray@totalise.co.uk) writes:

Congratulations on what must be by far the best and most comprehensive review of 'Stalker' on DVD I have seen.

I finally received the 'Stalker' DVD (R2) a couple of days ago (end April 2002). This is a couple of months later than the original release date. It appears that an option has now been added regarding the soundtrack. My DVD version has the choice of two soundtracks: (1) the original (mono) soundtrack or (2) a Dolby 5.1 soundtrack.

The Dolby soundtrack, although in glorious surround sound, is spoilt by the fiddling and adding 'effects' to the sound - as if the original was too 'ordinary'.

I have compared various passages (notably the wonderful journey on the railway trolley), and I preferred the original in all instances.

An excellent quality DVD. Was the original in two parts? I do not remember that. 'Solaris' was divided into two DVD (R2) discs as well. I must check out the 'hidden' extras you mention on 'Stalker'.

I am now waiting, impatiently, for my copy of 'Mirror' on DVD...again, long overdue.

Tim Gray

Cambridge, UK


Gunnar (gbangsmo@tiscali.no) writes:

I agree that Stalker is a GREAT film, and I believe this is one of the best -reviews I've read about it. I have to say though, in response to Isaac Calderón that the review does not compare Tarkovsky with von Trier, but the other way around. It IS von Trier that is influenced by Tarkovsky, and NOT the other way around. Maybe you should look into the HISTORY of film!


Erasmus Napier (Email address withheld) writes:

Excellent review. Longer piece on Tarkovsky?

Have just purchased the DVD in (of all places) Hollywood Discount DVD and Video on CXR. Felt peculiar when watching the opening scenes, not sure whether my eyes were deceiving me with the apparent floating of the white on sepia. Is there an _hommage_ to that opening tracking shot over the bed in _The Sweet Hereafter_?

Superlative, in any case.


Rosalía Sender Fuentes (rosaliasender@hotmail.com) writes:

I´d only suggest that maybe von Trier makes his films for our abstract faculties, meanwhile Tarkovski, in an ancient and almost antitheoretical approach to the image "as it is", makes his secuences like sculptures or doves.

Swaping, Spain


Natelle (natbe@hotmail.com) writes:

I saw this film on cable tv, and enjoyed it greatly. I enjoyed this review too. I did want to mention that I noticed that all the places in this movie were filled with human waste, and thought there was a little statement there about what we're doiing to the place that our children have to occupy later on--a message I rarely see and am hungry for. Natelle, San Diego, California


brad moore (bradanddiana@globaleyes.net) writes:

Every year, I watch Stalker, usually during the end of July, and the beguinning of August.I greatly look forward to the times of the year when I see my favorite films, almost like clockwork,to coincide with my moods and feelings. I also do this with films like:El Topo,The Holy Mountain, Blow Up, Nostalghia, The Hustler, Persona, and more.I am an artist and teacher. Brad Moore.I Just saw "Stalker" tonight! (7-16-03)See you in one year!!


Ranko (brtrenko@hotmail.com) writes:

Even more impressive is Arkady & Boris Strugatsky book "Roadside Picnic", which inspired Tarkovsky.

It depicts Zones as places where aliens landed, but not with intention to communicate with us, just as we have no idea what happends with all the tiny creatures, when we pack up the picnic and leave the trash behind...

its a must-read...

R.


ROBERT COHEN (DocOrgone@aol.com) writes:

So, it is now March 2004. Are the DVD's fixed now (audio) as we buy them NEW? Let's here what's going on.

Cheers.


Chernobyl / Revelations / Stalker (Email address withheld) writes:

In the Stalker one of the explanations given for the Zone's origin was a breakdown at the fourth bunker. This was six years before the fourth bunker in Chernobyl exploded and a 20 mile sealed off Zone created.

During the film Revelation 8:7-11 is eerily read:

The third angel blew his trumpet; and a great star shot from the sky, flaming like a torch; and it fell on a third of the rivers and springs. The name of the star was Wormwood; and a third of the water turned to wormwood, people in great numbers died of the water because it had been poisoned.

Whether you take it as wierd co-incidence or biblical fatalism, Chernobyl in Russian is "wormwood". Very strange in itself and even stranger in the context of this film.


Sickened!!! (oh yeah mars whatever!!@like I care anymore!) writes:

The film made me question what sort of a sicko would make such a comment (see above) Not impressed.


brad moore (bradanddiana@globaleyes.net) writes:

I am a bit late in returning my message concerning "Stalker" this year('04). I aquired a grand new roster of surreal films to add to my rack, and it pushed back my usual viewing of "Stalker" a few weeks. I did see it again, late this summer. I usually see it in the month of July, and look forward to it, as many of us do. It always has a particular power, in the right frame of mind, as most of the Tarkovsky works do. I watch Andrei Rublev at Christmas, or there-abouts. All the best, Brad Moore.


Alexey (Email address withheld) writes:

The film is quite prophetic, and the reason for the parallels with Chernobyl disaster, probably because Tarkovsky had Nuclear scientists friends, that told him of potential problems with nuclear reactors of that type.

Both Stalker & Solaris can be a bit difficult to watch but are worth it every time.


Add your comments about Stalker [About]




UTILITIES


Search kamera.co.uk

Product finder



Browse our network:




| WHO WE ARE | BLOG | BOOKSHOP | DIRECTORY | FORUM | INTERVIEWS | FEATURES | BOOK REVIEWS | FILM REVIEWS | FILM NEWS |   


kamera.co.uk

Copyright © 1999/2004 kamera.co.uk